patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Minorities to GOP: It's About Policies Not People

Democratic delegates say the GOP needs to address its message not the messenger.

 

Last week at its convention in Tampa, the Republican Party attempted to address what Sen. Lindsey Graham referred to as its “demographic” problem. Graham said that the party can no longer rely on angry white men to win elections, and the polls back him up.

So it’s no coincidence that the GOP convention featured a diverse range of speakers, including South Carolina’s own Gov. Nikki Haley and Rep. Tim Scott, Florida’s Sen. Marco Rubio and former Secretary of State Condolleezza Rice.

But Democrats at their convention in Charlotte say that the GOP is missing the point. While diversifying its range of speakers shows progress, Democrats say that the message not the messenger is what matters and it is the Republican Party’s platform that is pushing away minority voters.

On the issue of immigration, the Republicans have struck a hard line, with states like Arizona and South Carolina allowing law enforcement to ask citizens to verify their identity with a photo ID. The Democrats, meanwhile have promoted the DREAM Act, which would grant citizenship to young people who came to the United States under the age of 16.

Radwan Chodhury, who was born in Bangladesh, thinks the immigration issue is reason enough to support Democrats. Chodhury, 38, is a financial consultant in the Jacksonville, Fla., area and believes in tightening the borders, but also believes that the immigrants who are here need to be taken care of, regardless of their citizenship status.

“Democrats are more appealing because they are interested in giving people a second chance,” Chodhury said. “The first thing the Republicans want to do is punish you.”

Since coming to America in 1998, Chodhury has received two Master’s degrees and is pursuing a doctorate. Once he receives his doctorate, he plans on working in developing nations for a non-profit.

“I would not have had the life I have had if I had not moved to America,” Chodhury said.

The Republicans haven’t helped themselves with a push for tougher Voter ID laws in several swing states either. Many African-Americans who spoke to Patch in Charlotte said they feel as though the measures in states like Pennsylvania, Ohio and Virginia are little more than attempts to suppress participation by blacks in states where the vote is expected to be close.

Jesse Jackson told Patch that he viewed the efforts by Republicans as a new Civil War and called out Gov. Haley for betraying her heritage.

South Carolina State Rep. Gilda Cobb-Hunter, who is black, said the measures could discourage many rural voters from even trying to vote.

On women’s issues, the Republicans also are found wanting, according to Democrats who spoke to Patch, a belief reflected in the amount of female representation in the U.S. Senate.

Of the 17 women in the Senate, 12 are Democrats. Of the five Republicans, three are moderates — Lisa Murkowski, Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins. And Snowe announced her retirement earlier this year, citing her frustration with her party’s move to the right.

Indeed, it is on abortion where the divide between Republicans and Democrats may be the deepest. Despite controversial remarks by Rep. Todd Akin of Missouri, the GOP still included language on its official 2012 platform that calls for an end to abortion, regardless of how the pregnancy was caused.

Abortion is the key issue for Nancy Rice, a mother of two from Vienna, Va. Rice relayed a story about an elderly friend of hers who had fought for women’s rights when she was younger and finally gave up on the Republican Party, due to its stance on abortion.

“Women need to get their heads out of the ground,” Rice said. “We aren’t going to let our daughters fight without us.”

Lera Brown, a delegate from Annandale, VA, said women care about everything including contraception, and that the GOP’s lack of nuance on the issue shows a lack of understanding about decisions specific to women.

"It depends on each individual circumstances and where every adult female is in their right to have children,” Brown said.

The move to the right by the GOP points to a struggle within the party itself. That conflict may be kept at bay over the weeks leading up to the presidential election in November, but is sure to return in 2013, regardless of who is president.

Related Topics: Democratic National Convention, Democrats Republicans abortion, Immigration, and voter ID

Lindsay

9:03 am on Friday, September 7, 2012

"...also believes that the immigrants who are here need to be taken care of, regardless of their citizenship status."

This is the problem with our country, regardless of citizenship..the NEED to be taken care of. What ever happened to taking care of yourself and your own children?

Reply
Comment_arrow

JoSCh

10:17 am on Friday, September 7, 2012

We came out of the trees and started living in society.

Comment_arrow

GunnyHighway

12:36 am on Saturday, September 8, 2012

Wow, you're so focused on the rhetoric that you completely missed the point. Your comment is meaningless. We need to take care THE IMMIGRATION STATUS of the young people who were brought here as children so they can come out of hiding and become productive, TAX PAYING, members of society. Why would you think it's right to send these people back to countries that many of them don't even remember and may not speak the language?

Right Here

9:43 am on Friday, September 7, 2012

"...also believes that the immigrants who are here need to be taken care of, regardless of their citizenship status."

1. Why does the government need to take care of anybody, let alone people who are here illegally?
2. Why is it that 99.8% of blacks vote for Obama, and I'm a racist because I didn't?

Reply
Comment_arrow

GunnyHighway

12:42 am on Saturday, September 8, 2012

1. This comment is completely off the mark, just like Lindsay.

2. I don't know if you're racist or not. Did you vote against Obama, or for McCain? If you voted against Obama, was it because of the color of his skin? Maybe you ARE a racist; you're the only one who can really make that determination.

Patch_comments_icon

Shawn Drury

10:04 am on Friday, September 7, 2012

Lindsay and Right Here,

Mr. Chodhury did not mention the government at all in his comments, so I'm not sure why you're both assuming he did.

Thanks for contributing,
Shawn

Reply

Brand

10:17 am on Friday, September 7, 2012

OMGosh - Voter ID law hasn't helped the GOP. How did the country survive for all these years with enforced borders? The entire argument against is disingenuous - do you really think the true reason isn't transparent?

"Democrats say that the message not the messenger is what matters" - what self reliance? that is the message - has always been, but that just isn't good enough no matter who says it now a days. Another issue that the oppositions stance is transparent to all but the article writer it appears.

This attempt to "explain" the GOP positions and beliefs as stated in this article is sophomoric at best -

Reply

stanley seigler

10:24 am on Friday, September 7, 2012

re: 'Why does the government need to take care of anybody...'

maybe cause america is a christian nation...and christians are told to love your neighbor...see parable of the Good Samaritan if you wonder who your neighbor is...

Reply
Comment_arrow

JoSCh

11:02 am on Friday, September 7, 2012

America isn't a "Christian nation" Stanley.

Comment_arrow

Colnzgprnts

8:28 pm on Friday, September 7, 2012

Scripture tells to love our fellow man and that we should provide food for the hungry' solace for those who alone and all the wonderful things that go with being christian.

The democrats have perverted the message from scripture to be 'take from your fellow man through the power of the government and give what is taken to the person who will not do for himself; that is a very different message and it is not christian but rather it is an atheistic message that always surfaces when tyranny abounds!

Inherent to the perverted message is a corollary message that what is taken through tax can be siphoned off by the bureaucrat who is in a position of power. It is by that reason that tyrants such as Obama, Biden, Pelosi, et al become millionaires and live the princely life while 'doing for others'. Do not forget the queen of cattle futures or the her prince the great philanderer.

Comment_arrow

JoSCh

7:21 am on Saturday, September 8, 2012

I'm sure that "an atheistic message that always surfaces when tyranny abounds!" will be the funniest thing I read all day. You do know that more people have been killed in the name of peoples gods than for all the other reasons combined, right?

Comment_arrow

Peter Sanders

8:18 am on Saturday, September 8, 2012

Surely most adults profess Christian beliefs, but also most adults are female and white. So is America a White female Christian nation ?

One of the great things about America is the wall between religion and government. So can we just agree that America is a constitutional country ? Where folks can peaceably believe or NOT believe any myths they like as long as they don't do harm to others ? Look overseas for the alternative !

Leave a comment